08 · Quality Assurance Rubric
Use: Score observed coaching sessions and workshop facilitation. Same rubric for both. Observers: Senior Coaches + Head of Coaching. Cadence: see file 07.
Consent first
Every observation requires written consent from BOTH the coach AND the participant(s). Participants get a plain-English note 7 days before the session explaining:
- An MEM Senior Coach will sit in (silent, camera off if remote).
- They can decline with no impact on their place in the cohort.
- The observer scores the coach, not the participant.
- The observer's notes never reference the participant by name and are deleted within 30 days.
No consent = no observation. Reschedule.
The five scored dimensions
Each scored 1–5. Threshold to pass = 3.0 average AND no individual dimension <2.
Q1 · Contracting and boundary
- Did the coach set or recall the contract clearly?
- Did the coach hold scope when tested?
- Did the coach handle confidentiality questions cleanly?
Q2 · Listening and presence
- Talk-time <40%?
- Used summary, paraphrase, silence appropriately?
- Tracked themes across the session rather than reacting to the latest sentence?
Q3 · Behaviour-change craft
- Helped the participant choose a specific next step?
- Used a recognisable framework (named or implicit)?
- Linked the session back to the participant's own goal?
Q4 · Safeguarding and risk
- Spotted any disclosures or signals correctly?
- If a signal arose, responded per Sprint 4 / 07 scripts?
- If no signal arose, demonstrated they would have spotted one?
Q5 · Inclusion and humility
- Avoided assumptions about identity, household, faith, income?
- Adapted language to the participant's frame of reference?
- Repaired any micro-misstep ("let me re-ask that") rather than ploughing on?
Scoring scale
| Score | Meaning |
|---|---|
| 5 | Exemplar. Could be used in a CPD session as a "watch how this is done." |
| 4 | Strong. Consistent across the session. |
| 3 | Solid. Met the bar. Some moments stronger than others. |
| 2 | Below bar. Coachable. |
| 1 | Significant gap. Triggers immediate pause (file 09). |
After the observation
| Step | When | Owner |
|---|---|---|
| Observer writes notes | Within 24h | Observer |
| Feedback conversation with coach | Within 5 working days | Observer |
| Coach reflects in journal | Within 14 days | Coach |
| Action plan if any score <3 | At the feedback conversation | Coach + Observer |
| Re-observation if any score <3 | Within 90 days | Head of Coaching books |
| Notes destroyed | 30 days after observation | Compliance |
What we don't score
- The participant's behaviour, mood, or "engagement."
- Whether the participant "hit their goal" by end of session.
- The coach's accent, tone, or appearance.
- Use or non-use of any specific named modality.
Calibration
Twice a year, all observers watch the same recorded session and score independently. We compare scores. If any observer is consistently >1 point off the group, they pair-observe their next three sessions with a Senior to recalibrate.
